The internet in its current form is unsupportable and dangerous, according to
the man that led its inception.
Dr Larry Roberts led the team that designed and developed the web's
precursor,
Arpanet,
and is now chief executive of router vendor
Anagran.
Dr Roberts warned that poor programming means that the internet is growing
too fast for network infrastructure to cope. In addition, security is weaker
than it should be because of a lack of development within the TCP/IP standard.
"It has been 40 years and nothing has changed," he said. "Traffic is growing
faster than network costs are dropping. Moore's Law is not keeping up. The
network costs double every three years, and we cannot afford it any more."
Dr Roberts maintained that the industry needs to concentrate on sending
prioritised flows of data traffic rather than sending packets individually.
Doing this could cut the power consumption and size of network hardware by a
factor of five, according to Dr Roberts, which would buy some time.
He added that there are big problems with security in that user
authentication needs to be checked automatically, and the source of packets
needs to be checked.
Data flow records also need to be kept, which would help in dealing with
denial of service attacks.
Dr Roberts believes that it would be relatively easy to make the internet
secure, but that no-one is willing to do so because of the expense.
He is also in conversation with governments over plans to allow the emergency
services to get priority on internet traffic.
Fairness is also an issue, according to Dr Roberts. Peer-to-peer users take
up to 80 per cent of the available bandwidth at times, which is neither fair nor
rational.
But others disagree. Professor Lutz Heuser, chief development architect at
SAP, said: "We
have stretched TCP/IP as far as we can go. Do we really want to use 40 year-old
technology?"
But Roberts insisted that TCP/IP is sound, and just needs work on its
implementation.
"The problem is that we have ignored research into networking because we
thought that the problems were solved. They are not," he said.
Do you agree?
Have your say on this article